# Consciousness as Fundamental

By R.J. Hills, September 3, 2025. https://symbolmind.app/articles/consciousness-as-fundamental/

I keep a glass prism on the shelf beside me as a reminder of the true nature of consciousness. The shape of the glass determines how the light emerges on the other side, and that helps me picture what gives each of us a point of observation into a field of consciousness.

Let me start by talking about reductionism. You can imagine scientists examining the sparkles of light, billions of them, as they reflect off the surface of the ocean. We can study them and learn a good deal about the shape of the surface from what we see. With a traditional reductionist approach, we can detect individual photons and measure the wavelengths of the reflected light. But unless we step back and look up, we will never find the source of that light. The Sun.

Imagine a crow perched on the fence beside you. Something we would typically overlook in the grass might be incredibly attractive to the crow and give it a good reason to fly down.

To ask whether the crow and I are equally conscious already assumes that each of us holds a consciousness of our own and that we could somehow compare the two. If there’s a field of consciousness, the way I would put it is that the crow and I are each expressions in that field: very different and unique expressions, granted, but still expressions of a fundamental field.

Imagine two prisms of different shapes with the same light passing through them. A different projection emerges from the other side of each prism. Jim Carrey once described our eyes as projectors as well as viewers. I included that part in [my video about him](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r2A2p3pZ5hM).

## Outive proscope

It frustrates me when I hear what should be an intellectual discussion about consciousness completely gloss over the meaning of the word in the first place. In fact, I think we have several words packed into one: wakefulness, awareness of our surroundings, awareness of ourselves, and qualia, the felt quality of an experience, such as the redness of red. You won’t have to look very hard to find podcasts or conversations addressing questions like “Is AI conscious?” or “Is consciousness fundamental?” The discussion can go on for hours without anyone having a good grasp on the meaning of the word.

David Bohm played with language in what he called the [rheomode](https://www.routledge.com/Wholeness-and-the-Implicate-Order/Bohm/p/book/9780415289795), giving the verb the leading role so he could speak about something in motion. I run into the limitation he was getting at as soon as I say “my consciousness.” Before I’ve even begun to describe what’s happening, those words make it sound as though I possess something.

In revisiting my initial research I’m introducing a term of my own, *outive proscope*, for the first time in public. I use *outive* for expressing outward (the projection) and *proscope* for the part the instrument plays (the processes), as the prism does in the projection of light. The two words together describe the process by which activity in the brain allows us to be aware and gives each of us a point of observation into the field of consciousness.

Suppose you covered the prism in black paint. It would stop separating the white light into the spectrum of color you would see emerge on the other side. The light hasn’t gone anywhere, and you could take the paint off and see the colors again. That’s how I picture the loss of ordinary awareness under general anesthesia.

Now imagine the prism is cracked or broken. The light can still reach the glass, but what emerges on the other side depends on where the crack runs and how the pieces lie. That’s how I use the same analogy to think about brain damage. The brain certainly has a huge part to play in what a person can experience. Why would that mean consciousness itself has to be inside the brain, any more than the light emerging from the prism has to originate in the glass?

Stuart Hameroff and Sir Roger Penrose propose that moments of awareness arise when quantum states in microtubules, tiny structures inside neurons, collapse in a way that depends on the geometry of spacetime. They call this [orchestrated objective reduction](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24070914/). In my initial research I describe my framework as compatible with theirs, though it doesn’t require that quantum mechanism.

## What the glass contributes

In [*Human Immortality*](https://web.ics.purdue.edu/~drkelly/JamesHumanImmortalityTwoObjections1898.pdf), William James asks what we mean when we say thought depends on the brain. One of his examples is colored glass. Change the glass in a window and you can change the color of the light coming into the room, which is quite a contribution for something that would sit there in the dark all night until the sun came round again.

To explain why the red emerges from the prism at a particular angle you’d have to take the glass into account, the light coming through it, and the angle at which you hold it. Where in that arrangement would you go looking for the red that *you* see?

In *Connections*, a book I’m still drafting, I asked whether the brain itself might be a sensory organ. When the red light from the prism reaches the [retina at the back of my eye](https://www.nei.nih.gov/eye-health-information/healthy-vision/how-eyes-work), cells there turn it into electrical signals, and the retina itself develops as an outgrowth of the brain.

David Bohm uses a hologram to get at something similar in [*Wholeness and the Implicate Order*](https://www.routledge.com/Wholeness-and-the-Implicate-Order/Bohm/p/book/9780415289795). A small piece of a holographic plate can still give you a view of the whole scene, though you lose some detail. It’s an odd result if you’re used to photographs. Cut a photograph of your family in half and you’re left with half the family, but cut the corner off a hologram of them and you’d find everyone still in it.

Bohm calls the order in which the whole image is folded into the plate *implicate*, and the order in which the figures appear beside one another *explicate*. That makes sense to me as a way of thinking about the crow. There’s one world here, and what comes into view from the fence depends a great deal on who’s doing the looking.

## An avalanche in a piece of tissue

John Beggs and Dietmar Plenz put thin slices of rat brain tissue on a grid of electrodes. They [recorded bursts of electrical activity](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/14657176/) that might register at only a few places on the grid, or spread much farther before dying out. Small bursts were common and big ones rare, with a pattern in the sizes that reminded the researchers of avalanches.

Think of adding grains to a pile of sand. One grain can come to rest where it lands, another can dislodge a few neighbors, and every so often a good part of the slope gives way. You could have a very steady hand and add the same amount each time. The idea behind *self-organized criticality* is that a pile can arrive at that delicate state through the very process of adding grains and letting them fall.

What caught my interest in that experiment was the range of sizes. There was no single typical avalanche that the rest clustered around. That’s one reason I became interested in fractals, where you can look at a pattern on quite different scales and still recognize something of the same arrangement. My proposal is that activity in a handful of cells can take part in a pattern stretching across whole regions of the brain. It’s quite a step from an electrode picking up a burst to someone recognizing a familiar voice.

There’s another sense in which a brain might be close to a tipping point. When Daniel Toker and his colleagues [compared recordings during wakefulness, anesthesia, and generalized seizures](https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8851554/), the slow electrical rhythms they studied in the waking brain lay near a boundary between stable and chaotic activity. What I found particularly interesting was that the rhythms moved away from that boundary in opposite directions under anesthesia and during a seizure. Simply asking whether there was *more* activity would miss what had changed.

## Where the loop closes

Douglas Hofstadter’s [*I Am a Strange Loop*](https://www.hbglibrary.com/titles/douglas-r-hofstadter/i-am-a-strange-loop/9780465008377/) sits beside my bed. He asks how a brain that builds up a picture of the world comes to include a picture of itself among the things in it. Place two mirrors facing each other and the reflections cascade for infinity, although you’d be hard pressed to point to the place where a third mirror had appeared. Imagine you could now focus anywhere in that cascade of reflections. Now we’re getting close to how I view consciousness.

In meditation I’ve pictured those facing mirrors as a way of understanding a loop I felt during a psychedelic experience. I see consciousness as fundamental, and it’s the back and forth, the oscillation I picture in those mirrors, that gives me a point of observation in that field. I can hear a sound, notice myself listening to it, and then turn my attention to the one who noticed.

Suppose it’s a familiar voice you hear on the other end of a phone. You can recognize your mother in the way she says your name before she’s even finished saying it. Where would you draw the line between hearing her voice and remembering it? In my initial research I asked whether the brain’s default mode network might help bring the activity of many smaller groups of cells into step.

I used the word *crystallization* for what I imagine happens when activity poised near a critical point can form patterns across several scales and feed back on itself. A crystal takes a particular shape as it forms. In my account, what takes shape is a point of view, with all the particular things that make a voice familiar to me. The person at the next table might hear exactly the same words and have no idea who’s speaking.

There’s a question in there that an experiment could answer. I’d expect the coordination between small groups of cells and larger regions to change as someone passes under anesthesia and to return as they wake. If people could consistently report an experience while the coordination I’m proposing was absent, I’d have to rethink that part. Even a perfect match, though, would leave me with the question I had about the reflection on the water. Knowing exactly when the glint appears still leaves open where the light comes from.

When I sit down to meditate and hear the bowl sound, I can follow the note until I’m no longer quite sure whether I can hear it or whether I remember hearing it a moment ago. As a music producer and audio engineer, I’d only have to look at the waveform to see exactly where the ring falls silent. What the waveform can’t show me is the sound that lingers in my memory after it has ended.

## Sources

1. William James, [*Human Immortality*](https://web.ics.purdue.edu/~drkelly/JamesHumanImmortalityTwoObjections1898.pdf), Ingersoll Lecture (1898 edition).
2. David Bohm, [*Wholeness and the Implicate Order*](https://www.routledge.com/Wholeness-and-the-Implicate-Order/Bohm/p/book/9780415289795), Routledge (1980).
3. John M. Beggs and Dietmar Plenz, [“Neuronal Avalanches in Neocortical Circuits”](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/14657176/), *Journal of Neuroscience* (2003).
4. Daniel Toker and colleagues, [“Consciousness Is Supported by Near-Critical Slow Cortical Electrodynamics”](https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8851554/), *Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences* (2022).
5. Douglas Hofstadter, [*I Am a Strange Loop*](https://www.hbglibrary.com/titles/douglas-r-hofstadter/i-am-a-strange-loop/9780465008377/), Basic Books (2007).
6. R.J. Hills, “Consciousness as Fundamental: Fractal-Criticality Framework,” initial research, September 2025.
7. Jim Carrey, [speech at Maharishi University of Management](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V80-gPkpH6M) (2014). Excerpt in [*Jim Carrey’s Awakening*](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r2A2p3pZ5hM), Source Potential.
8. R.J. Hills, “The Human Framework,” chapter 1 of *Connections*, a book in draft.
9. Stuart Hameroff and Roger Penrose, [“Consciousness in the universe: A review of the ‘Orch OR’ theory”](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24070914/), *Physics of Life Reviews* (2014).

## Pictures

- David Bohm: Physicist and author of Wholeness and the Implicate Order. Photographer unknown, used as commentary. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Bohm
- Douglas Hofstadter: At Stanford in 2006. Photo: null0, CC BY-SA 2.0. https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Douglas_Hofstadter,_Stanford_2006_(crop).jpg

Symbol Mind’s guided meditations leave long stretches of silence in which to explore what it feels like to be the one listening. https://symbolmind.app/
