Symbol Mind
Articles

Separation Is an Illusion

“But we are actually in the mountains,” I said to a visitor at our cabin who’d hoped for a better view. How often do you make much the same mistake about your place in nature?

Someone visiting our cabin was disappointed with the view because the trees were in full leaf and you could hardly see the mountains through them. From where I stood I could see the stream and the birds, and raindrops falling from the leaves overhead. I could smell the damp earth and feel the fresh air filling my lungs, and I’d argue that being there in the middle of all that was a far richer experience than looking out at the sort of mountain view you’d put on a postcard.

I remember Alan Watts talking about a visit to Japan and the tourists who seemed to see everything through the viewfinders of their cameras. I often think of that in airports and waiting rooms these days, where you can be sitting among dozens of people and what seems to hold so many of them transfixed is that little rectangle in the palm of their hand.

Ask someone to picture nature and they’ll probably describe a forest or a mountainside, though a city might take a little more prompting, let alone the device you’re reading this on. I’d be curious to know whether the person doing the looking gets a place in that picture. Standing at the cabin with the mountain air in my lungs, I was as much a part of that scene as the birds in the trees.

The body

If most people are asked where their body ends, they’d probably point to their skin. Some of the bacteria in a person’s gut help digest the food they eat, and in return the person provides a very agreeable place for those bacteria to live. There may be roughly as many bacterial cells as human ones inside that skin. When someone points to it, which of those cells are they counting as part of themselves?

Most of our cells depend on mitochondria for energy, and Lynn Margulis made the case that the ancestors of those mitochondria were bacteria that came to live inside other cells. Why would someone count the mitochondria as part of their body and call the bacteria in their gut guests? What strikes me is how much a person depends on both.

When I draw a breath, some of the oxygen that was in the air around me passes into my blood. At what point would you say it became part of me? I could ask much the same question about the water I drink or the food I eat.

If someone loses a leg, are they any less the person they were? Most people would probably locate the self somewhere in the head, and I don’t doubt that thinking is something the brain does. But when you really think about it, pun intended, are my thoughts who I am, any more than my toe is?

In Advaita Vedanta, whose name means “not two,” there’s a practice called neti neti that takes its wording from the Brihadaranyaka Upanishad. With each “not this, not this,” you set aside something you might take yourself to be, whether it’s your leg, your toe, or the thought you’ve just had, until you’re left wondering who’s doing the looking.

The circle and the wave

Try drawing just the inside of a circle with your finger in the sand and see how you get on. By the time you’ve closed the circle, you’ve given it an outside too, which is what George Spencer-Brown means by making a distinction at the beginning of his book Laws of Form.

A ring of colored sand on a black plate

Alan Watts liked to show this with a blackboard, where he’d draw a circle and ask his audience what he’d drawn. I remember one talk where someone called out, “A hole in the wall,” and Watts laughed and said, “You’ve been reading my books!” Most people, he went on, would say a circle, a ball, a sphere. The Eastern view Watts spent his life explaining, and one I share with him, goes back thousands of years to Lao Tzu, who saw the same relationship between long and short in the Tao Te Ching.

So it is that existence and non-existence give birth the one to (the idea of) the other; that difficulty and ease produce the one (the idea of) the other; that length and shortness fashion out the one the figure of the other…

Lao Tzu, Tao Te Ching, chapter 2, translated by James Legge (1891)

I can call something long all day, but sooner or later somebody’s going to ask, “Compared with what?” When I use the word “me” I’ve drawn a little circle around myself, and in doing so I’ve brought the rest of the world into the picture, because I needed it to make the distinction in the first place.

If I tried to catch a wave in a jar to show my family, all I’d have when I got home would be a jar of water. I’d do better to tell them how the ocean rose and curled over just where I dipped the jar, because what the ocean was doing at that moment is what made it a wave. I think that’s what Watts was getting at in his talk about our place in nature when he compared a wave to a person.

You are something the whole universe is doing in the same way that a wave is something that the whole ocean is doing.

Alan Watts, “Man in Nature,” The Tao of Philosophy (1965)

When a frog jumps into a pond, you can measure the distance between the ripples in inches and get a perfectly good answer. Where would you go looking for one of those inches in the pond afterwards? We supplied the inch, just as we supply the mile and the hour. As for what actually happened, try describing those ripples while leaving out either the frog that jumped or the water it jumped into.

If you imagine lifting the ocean off the earth, you can picture the planet in one place and a body of water in another. It’s easy enough to separate the two in your head, but what does that tell you about the ocean as it actually exists on earth? I could separate my brain from my skull, too, but I wouldn’t be alive to see it. What would that prove?

When sunlight catches the waves I find the glints on the water even more beautiful than the sun in the sky. I can point to one in particular, and a moment later the water has moved and I’ve lost it. It makes sense to me that a person could be an individual in much the same way. There’s only one view from where I’m standing, although everything that makes the view possible extends well beyond my skin.

Why meditate

If we’re sitting together and I’m thirsty, it matters which of us picks up the glass and drinks. I suspect our survival depends on being able to make that distinction. And whatever the limits of my particular point of view, it’s from here that I get to know and love anybody else. I’m in no hurry to give that up.

Lao Tzu, Ram Dass, and Alan Watts all tried to convey what it means to be the universe, and I could tell you that you are the universe, but you’d only be taking my word for it. Meditation gives you a way to look into it for yourself, if you’re curious, although I don’t think anyone has to see through the illusion to live a full life.

Whether you’ve reached enlightenment or have yet to give it a moment’s thought, the old Zen saying has you out chopping wood and carrying water. Its roots go back to Layman Pang, a Chinese Chan Buddhist of the eighth century who counted fetching water and firewood among his marvels. I think what changes is how you see that work and who you understand yourself to be while you do it. If you’ve ever been lost in a city and suddenly recognized where you were, did you stop to explain your discovery to everyone you met, or did you carry on with your journey?

When I say it isn’t a problem if you never meditate, I mean it much the same way it isn’t a problem whether I drink coffee or tea. If there’s a tree in my garden and I dig it up and plant a cactus in its place, at what point did that become a problem? I dare say you’d have an answer if you’d been hoping to sit in the shade, but it takes one of us to say why we’d have preferred the tree.

For a parent sitting beside a child who has leukemia, what counts as a problem is perfectly clear. From the point of view of the whole universe, who is there to decide such a thing? And if I try to take that wider view, how could I leave out the parent sitting beside the bed, for whom it matters so much?

When I sit down to meditate with something troubling me, I can notice how much of my attention has gone into what might happen tomorrow. If I were the one sitting beside that bed, I’d want to be able to bring my attention back long enough to hear what my child was saying to me today.

Pictures

Symbol Mind begins with a circle drawn in sand, its inside and its outside one and the same.

Guided meditation with few words, long silences, and the sound of real places.

And a meditation timer with binaural beats.

Download on the App Store

Free to start. No account needed.