Symbol Mind
Articles

The Space Between

Meditation and a psychedelic experience brought me to what I call the Space Between, something I can recognize in the pause after a breath. But, what does that small stillness have to do with the way the whole universe takes shape?

Of all the things I’ve tried to put into words, one of the hardest is a psychedelic experience in which I felt as though I almost existed in the empty space itself. I wonder what you picture when I say “empty.” The word suggests darkness or the absence of something, and yet what I remember most clearly is how at home I felt there.

In The Doors of Perception, Aldous Huxley describes three flowers in a little glass vase in his study. He gives the color of a rose petal so precisely that I can picture the deeper pink at its base. What’s harder, even for a writer like Huxley, is to convey to someone who’s never had such an experience what it felt like to look at that rose and be struck by the sheer fact that it existed.

The vase

When I meditate, I often place my attention on the space between breaths. Paying attention only to the breath feels a little like admiring a vase for its shape and its glaze. What I recognize in both Alan Watts and the Tao Te Ching is the importance of the space inside it, because you could fill that vase with clay and still admire it all day without being able to put a single flower in it.

Lao Tzu described how thirty spokes meet at the hub of a wheel and how it’s the hole through that hub, where the axle goes, that makes the wheel useful. A potter shapes the clay around the hollow that will hold the water, and when we build a room it’s the space we leave between the walls that we get to live in. Even the Tao itself, in Lao Tzu’s account, has that quality of an empty vessel.

The Tao is (like) the emptiness of a vessel; and in our employment of it we must be on our guard against all fulness.

Lao Tzu, Tao Te Ching, chapter 4, translated by James Legge (1891)

When a professor visits a Zen master in the old story, the master pours him a cup of tea and keeps pouring until the tea runs over onto the table. When the professor protests that the cup is full, the master asks what more the professor expects to take in when he’s as full of his own opinions as the cup is of tea. I wonder how often people come to a conversation with so much they want to say that there’s very little room for the person they’ve come to hear.

Ma and jijimuge

I’d been fascinated by Japanese language and philosophy for years when I started looking into that moment between breaths and came across the word “ma.” It can be the part of an ink painting left bare, the silence between two notes of music, or the moment in a conversation when neither person speaks. When the architect Arata Isozaki brought an exhibition about ma to Paris in 1978, he presented it as space and time held in a single word. In the character 間, the sun sits inside a gate, and what I see when I look at it is sunlight shining through the gaps in that gate.

The same character turns up in the Japanese word for a human being, ningen (人間), written with the characters for “person” and “between.” The philosopher Watsuji Tetsurō built his ethics on it: a person exists in the space between people, in what he called betweenness, never as a sealed-off individual. I find it remarkable that a language writes the space between us into the very word for what we are.

Alan Watts introduced me to jijimuge, an idea from the Huayan school of Buddhism, known in Japan as Kegon. Watts translated it as the mutual interpenetration of all things and events, meaning there’s no barrier between one thing and the next. The old image for it is Indra’s net, a web strung with jewels in which every jewel reflects every other.

In seventh-century China, the Huayan teacher Fazang is said to have set up a room for the Empress Wu with mirrors on every side, above and below, and a statue of the Buddha and a lamp at the center. Every mirror held the statue and every other mirror, reflections inside reflections without end. To me, ma and jijimuge point at the same thing: the space between two things is where they meet.

As a music producer I spend quite a bit of time looking at waveforms on an oscilloscope. With a sine wave on the screen, I can follow the curve from a peak down through the middle to a trough and back up again, all while I hear one steady note. I can point to either end of that movement, but what would be left of the note if I held the wave still at its peak?

In The World as Self, Alan Watts asks what half a wave would amount to. He goes from the vibrations we hear as sound to the rhythm of a breath, then to a rise and fall that takes a whole human lifetime. On my screen it’s easy to see why there can’t be a peak without a trough. I think life and death belong to one another in much the same way.

The uncarved block

One morning, putting my socks on, I observed myself putting my socks on. I wouldn’t call it an out-of-body experience, but it was something like that. Then I noticed that I was observing myself without noticing. That’s why I created a meditation called Notice Not Noticing. When I try to see where the one doing the noticing fits into all of this, it gets rather hard to say where the observer ends and the thing being observed begins.

Standing in front of a blank canvas with a brush in your hand, you could say there’s nothing there, but where would you paint without that space? And what moved you to touch the brush to the canvas in the first place, when you had so little idea what the finished picture would look like?

In the Tao Te Ching, Lao Tzu often returns to the image of pu, the uncarved block, a piece of wood that still holds every form it could take. I felt it myself one night when I was sitting in bed looking out the window at Sirius, the brightest star in the night sky. It was shortly after I’d read the Tao Te Ching, and in that moment I felt I was the uncarved block, one with the star, almost as if I were looking at myself and the star was looking back.

Sitting there, I was overwhelmed with emotion, and the words I’d found in the book can only take me so far in describing it. I find it much easier to explain the idea of the uncarved block than to tell you what it felt like to look up at Sirius and recognize myself.

Scaffolding

When a snowflake lands on your sleeve and you can make out its pattern, at what point on the way down would you say it got that shape? The sixfold symmetry comes from the way water molecules fit together in ice. As the crystal travels through the cloud, changes in temperature and humidity affect how each arm branches. Had the wind carried it another way, you might be looking at quite a different pattern on your sleeve.

So how much of the world would you have to include to account for that one snowflake? You’d have to include the cloud, the wind that carried it, and whatever set that air in motion. You could start with a flower or with your own body and ask much the same question. What I’m trying to bring into view is the structure of the entire universe, not just a single object. I call the movement of that whole scaffolding because, as I see it, that’s where pattern originates.

Suppose the whole universe were made of glass, and see if you can picture it without giving it an edge. As soon as I imagine a great glass sphere, I’ve put myself somewhere outside it looking in. If there’s only glass, with no outer surface and no boundary anywhere within it, where could I point and say that one thing ends here and another begins?

As soon as a fine crack appears in the glass, there’s a line I can follow with my eye. If it branches, I can trace a pattern where a moment ago there was nothing to distinguish one place from the next. It brings to mind the word fractal, which Benoît Mandelbrot took from fractus, a Latin word that shares its root with fracture. If that were a crack in my window I’d say the glass was damaged, but in the universe I’m imagining, it’s that little space opening up that allows anything to take shape at all.

I remember Professor Chew Lock Yue starting with a line and then a square in a lecture at Nanyang Technological University. Two copies of a line segment half as long fit along the original, and it takes four squares with sides half as long to cover the original square. What interests me about the glass comes a step earlier. Before I could count two of anything, I’d need some way to tell one part from another.

The slightest turn of a kaleidoscope changes the whole view at once, which is about as close as I can get to picturing scaffolding. The difficulty I have with that comparison is that I could keep turning the thing all afternoon and every pattern I saw would still owe its symmetry to the fixed angles of the mirrors.

In Wholeness and the Implicate Order, David Bohm called the undivided movement of the whole the holomovement, and he described the forms we see as unfolding from that movement and folding back into it. I think he and I are pointing at the same thing, although if I say “scaffolding” you might well picture something standing perfectly still against the side of a building.

Bohm took that difficulty seriously enough to give verbs the leading role in an experiment with language he called the rheomode. Think of the word “tree,” then walk up to a tree and put your hand on the bark. How much of what’s under your hand did those four letters give you? The word “water” can never quench your thirst.

When I point to where my dog’s toy is, he looks at my finger, which I suppose is what’s meant by the finger pointing at the moon. I use the word “scaffolding” much as I use that finger, to draw your attention to where the pattern comes from, whatever word you might use for it.

Filling the space

On a walk recently, an older gentleman passed me with music blaring from his phone’s speaker. I could hear deer rustling in the leaves, birds calling, and the wind in the trees. My first thought was that the walk was already complete without the music. Well, it was, and once he came along the music was part of the walk too.

In John Cage’s 4′33″, first performed near Woodstock, New York, in 1952, the pianist sits at the piano and plays nothing for four minutes and thirty-three seconds, leaving everyone to listen to whatever sounds happen to be there. In his account of the premiere, Cage recalled hearing the wind outside during the first movement, rain on the roof during the second, and the audience talking and walking out during the third. The year before, he had sat in a soundproof room at Harvard expecting silence and still heard sounds, and he came away certain there’s no such thing as silence.

I preferred the sound of the deer rustling in the leaves, and that tells you something about me. What could it possibly tell you about the gentleman walking past? I think a good deal of trouble comes from that little step between “I’d rather hear the birds” and “he shouldn’t be playing that.” Meditation teaches me to recognize a preference for what it is, let him get on with his walk, and listen again to what’s there on mine.

Pictures

The Space Between is a meditation in Symbol Mind, and a guide you can read for free.

Guided meditation with few words, long silences, and the sound of real places.

And a meditation timer with binaural beats.

Download on the App Store

Free to start. No account needed.